Oor vambu
There is a tamil saying in my native which goes like ‘Virudhu patti saniyanai velai kuduthu vangaraan’.. well I did not get into this one voluntarily. It came right into my mailbox, only this time to my office mail box (vatsa..you are going to pay for it….grr).
So what is the vambu? Should RBI be ashamed of an invalid email ID it had in its website or not?
I tried to ignore this but I had some comments. As some of my regulars know, I really cannot resist revealing my ignorance:(
NV sir, with whom I am in telephone talking terms had written this post.
Well, I agree that it would’ve been better if the email had been a valid one.
That said, I would not judge RBI with an email link. Its like saying, ‘Ben Bernanke does not shave regularly, that is shameful etc’. We don’t judge Bernanke by his shaving skills or nose picking skills or whatever. Same applies for RBI too. RBI ensured that banking to a large extent remained a boring business, the way it should be, while some other central banks let some wealthy folks have fun.
In general NV sir and some other folks write only about India’s glory
. I’ve written enough on this topic. There are a few who support such viewpoints. Nowadays I am inclined to think that the perception of an RI about India, and that of an USRI about India shall never meet.
The RI’s is too focused on her own micro world while a USRI always forms her perception about what the media has to say, she sees during her three week trip. Based on these sometimes true observations and sometimes confirmation bias, they somehow decide life in India is hell. Its like the way we normal persons somehow assume that a blind person can never enjoy life. We see them as lacking faculties we have and so assume they can’t possibly ever be happy in their life.
And regarding building perceptions, the media is doing an amazing job. Till last week it was H1N1 ‘pandemic’. Anyone who had followed the media in the last two weeks would’ve thought there is a massive H1N1 outbreak in Velachery area and thousands of folks are already terminally infected. Folks who had no clue about the right usage of masks were using it left, right and center. In short, it was ’social proof’ tendency in all its glory. And just to make myself clear, these are innate human tendencies played out in all the countries at various times. Eventually, people figured out that the world did not end as they initially thought. Meanwhile Jaswant Singh decided ‘enough is enough’ and did something in national interest. Next thing we know, H1N1 is slowly fading from the media’s radar.
Two people were killed by a gunman in Neelankarai yesterday. Of course this news will remain in the headlines for the next few days in the local media. And those living far outside India are at their own liberty to form opinions as to how Chennai is fast becoming a violent, brutal, unsafe city, how they’ve always known ECR is totally crime prone. When the average RI in Neelankarai is too worried about Sonia Aggarwal’s career prospects, love life, and in what way had Andrea contributed to the divorce, and how he always knew something like this would happen. The concern of the former, is it any different from the concern of the latter? Nah. All are very valid concerns.
August 26th, 2009 at 7:27 am
I googled that email error msg in that blog post you linked to and was satisfied that the error was more or less due to what I suspected.
August 26th, 2009 at 9:11 am
PK
RBI email error = Bernanke’s beard?
Wrong analogy.IMHO.
I would rather - If Bernanke as the chairman of Fed has a beard..it better be neat and well groomed !! If not I would call it ‘Shameful’.
I stay my words - It’ too bad that an organization like RBI has a web presence, which IMHO , isn’t maintained !! So, even this day and age, if let’s say a businenessman ( forget commen man like me) has a question, he has to go to the bank in person ( will the phones work? will they answer) …vs..looking it up from the NET while he lives in some village !!
By the way, another question on RBI’s website. How can we be surre that the content in RBI’s website is current? Let’s forget the email etc!
August 26th, 2009 at 8:25 pm
NV sir,
trying to be objective…’shameful’ is too strong a word…I am ok with a not so well groomed beard as well..so long as Bernanke does the job.
same goes for RBI.
reg. content.. I do not think the RBI site was designed by a proper info. architect and maintained by a professional team which earns their idlies and dosais by maintaining sites…its probably under the control of some bureaucrat who knows very little about it… i am sure some guys there equate ‘website’ with technology rather than with media…
Same goes for irctc, the site is pathetic when you compare with cleartrip and makemytrip… but we do not judge railways with irctc…do we?
i do not understand what you mean by ‘this day and age’..the broadband penetration in the whole of india should be in single digit percentages… there is no sec 508 Rehabilitation Act. 1973 compliance in India as is the case in US (for challenged people)…website is not half as serious business here…
Some folks in RBI saw the Fed’s website and decided they too should have one…and they perhaps modeled one based on that..
BTW, I checked some of the pages on the Fed
http://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs.htm.. they’ve clearly given the last update as March 31, 2009…
http://www.federalreserve.gov/feedback.cfm
was last updated on December 3, 2004
not sure if we can call it current…
hopefully nothing has changed in the last 5 months or five years as the case maybe in matters relating to that page…
idhukaaga Fed kevalam nu thitta mudiyadhu…they are after all govt. related and we all know what to expect from bureaucracy…
I do not judge fed/rbi by their website maintenance…that is not their expertise.